Def Leppard: Officially A Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Inductee:
Def Leppard was FINALLY inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in 2019!
The band had been eligible since 2005, which still brings into question the Hall of Fame’s nomination and selection process — for example, Janet Jackson was also a 2019 inductee; is that fair when so many other deserving ROCK artists await their turn?
The argument detailed below questioning the Hall of Fame’s credibility continues, as does which music acts they ultimately deem more worthy over others — including, should Bon Jovi have been inducted before Def Leppard?
Def Leppard / Bon Jovi Tour:
Def Leppard “supported” Bon Jovi for select European concert dates in 2019.
“Co-headlining” would have made more sense, and the comparisons in the article below between Def Leppard and Bon Jovi are all the more relevant and applicable.
Which band REALLY deserves to be the headlining act? Enjoy the read below!
You might have a particular music artist who hasn’t been inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, but after so many years of waiting for their time to come, you no longer care.
That being the case, it’s still bothersome that the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame committee voted in Bon Jovi before Def Leppard, not to mention snubbed Def Leppard since 2005 (the year the band first became eligible).
What added to this irritation were articles stressing — or attempting to validate — why Bon Jovi’s accomplishments deemed them more than worthy for induction.
After reading through critics’ rationale and all the contributions they cite for Bon Jovi, it further convinced me that Def Leppard should have been in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame first.
Bon Jovi’s Achievements are “Slippery When Wet” Compared to Def Leppard
Here are some excerpts from articles I’ve seen defending Bon Jovi’s induction…
Article: Rolling Stone – “Why Bon Jovi Belong in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame”
- “Their blending of arena-rock largesse, pyrotechnic riffing and good-time vibes…led to some of the most pleasure-inducing rock hits of the Eighties and Nineties.”
- “‘Born to Be My Baby’… is peak synth-metal, an attempt to reach the grandiosity of their contemporaries Def Leppard.”
- “Their widespread appeal and hooky anthems helped them become one of the standard-bearers for Eighties hard rock…the American counterpart to the British rock fortress-builders Def Leppard.”
- “Their induction into the Rock Hall in April will help enshrine one of the biggest musical movement of the Eighties…”
Article: Forbes – “Yes, Bon Jovi Deserved Their Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame Induction — Here’s Why”
- “Their Rock Hall induction is a populist victory for a genre that depends on the unadulterated pleasures of its listeners.”
- “No listener…can resist a good pop song”
- “Always existed outside the ’80s ‘hair metal’ zeitgeist”
- “They crafted euphoric stadium rock anthems that blended masterful guitar work with unshakeable pop hooks.”
- “These songs have transcended generations and kept them an active touring juggernaut for more than 30 years.”
- “Bon Jovi enjoyed their unquestionable commercial peak in the ’80s, but the next two decades proved their resilience as the rock world underwent massive tidal shifts.”
- “Still sell out arenas around the world”
- “Pumped out feel-good karaoke staples that defined an era.”
What Is The Criteria For The Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame?
The article goes on to say that, “The Rock Hall determines an artist’s eligibility based on ‘influence on other performers and genres; length and depth of career and catalog; stylistic innovations; or superior technique and skills.'”
Does Bon Jovi Really Outshine Def Leppard?
Before I continue, I want to make it clear that my main issue isn’t with Bon Jovi.
This argument can apply to other artists already in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame and the many other acts whose fans feel are continuously snubbed. Some examples include Boston, Iron Maiden (lead singer Bruce Dickinson’s opinion of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame includes his belief, “It’s run by a bunch of sanctimonious bloody Americans who wouldn’t know rock ‘n’ roll if it hit them in the face…”), Motley Crue, T-Rex, and so on. To each their own.
My issue is specifically with the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame’s selection/voting process. The inconsistency in the “rock & roll” artists they’re nominating and inducting is baffling and borderline ridiculous.
It makes you wonder — are they nominating just to nominate? Is it their goal to reach a certain number of nominations annually just to fill a quota instead of truly considering worthy rock & roll acts — after all, this is the ROCK & ROLL Hall of Fame — who’ve earned it, regardless of how many nominees there are in a particular year?
Rise Up, Gather Round: Def Leppard vs. Bon Jovi
Let’s take a closer look at Def Leppard’s stats and accomplishments.
Def Leppard is one of only five rock acts that has two or more albums that are Diamond certified (10 million U.S. copies sold). The other rock acts in this elite club that have achieved this feat in their careers are The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, and Van Halen. Def Leppard accomplished it with back-to-back albums!
But if you were to compare Bon Jovi vs. Def Leppard — have a band “face-off,” if you will — it’s quite interesting to look at each band’s two biggest selling albums.
Oh, and before we begin, saying that Bon Jovi led the way with their style of music doesn’t fly — Bon Jovi formed in 1983. Def Leppard started in 1977, and for the record, “Slippery When Wet” came out 3 years after “Pyromania.”
Here are the stats…
First, “Slippery When Wet” vs. “Pyromania”…
Slippery When Wet
(3rd studio album)
(3rd studio album)
|U.S. Sales:||12x Platinum||10x Platinum|
|Peak Album Chart Position:||#1||#2 (second only to Thriller)|
|Popular Songs:||“You Give Love A Bad Name”||“Rock of Ages”|
|“Livin’ on a Prayer”||“Photograph“|
|“Wanted Dead of Alive”||“Foolin'”|
|“Never Say Goodbye”||“Too Late for Love”|
|Other Notable Tracks:||“Let It Rock,” “Raise Your Hands,” “I’d Die For You,” “Wild in the Streets”||“Rock Rock Til You Drop,” “Stagefright,” “Billy’s Got A Gun,” “Die Hard the Hunter”|
And now… “New Jersey” vs. “Hysteria”…
(4th studio album)
(4th studio album)
|U.S. Sales:||7x Platinum||12x Platinum|
|Peak Album Chart Position:||#1||#1|
|Popular Songs:||“Bad Medicine”||“Animal”|
|“Born to Be My Baby”||“Hysteria”|
|“I’ll Be There For You”||“Love Bites”|
|“Lay Your Hands On Me”||“Pour Some Sugar On Me”|
|“Living in Sin”||“Armageddon It”|
|Other Notable Tracks:||“Blood on Blood,” “Wild is the Wind,” “Stick to Your Guns”||“Women,” “Gods of War,”
“Love and Affection”
Do these album face-offs leave you thinking that Bon Jovi’s slate of songs overpower Def Leppard’s?
Better yet, is it even a fair fight to compare “New Jersey” to “Hysteria”?
I haven’t even touched on each band’s earlier albums — I’m talking about “Bon Jovi” and “7800° Fahrenheit” vs. “On Through The Night” and “High N’ Dry.”
If anyone wants to bring up early Bon Jovi tracks like “Runaway” or “In and Out of Love,” I’m happy to match and raise you a “Rock Brigade,” “Wasted,” “Let it Go,” “High N’ Dry (Saturday Night)” or “Bringin’ on the Heartbreak.” Take your pick!
Of course, comparing Def Leppard to Bon Jovi can simply be considered a fun exercise, but I don’t doubt at least some friendly competition between the bands over the years.
I’m reminded of a quote I read in a magazine interview with Joe Elliott back in the ’80s, when he said this:
“I think that Livin’ On A Prayer is possibly one of the best rock songs that’s ever been written! Pop-rock song. I don’t think they would have written that song if Photograph hadn’t come out.” (Rock of The 80’s II Magazine)
“Is Def Leppard In The Hall Of Fame” Shouldn’t Even Be A Question…
Much can be said about Def Leppard’s impressive legacy…
- Their quintessential album and biggest tour were accomplished AFTER the band re-emerged with a one-armed drummer. Just a fact, not a sympathy vote. Talk about groundbreaking perseverance!
- Riffs and multi-layered productions remain Def Leppard’s calling card, and something many have copied.
- Robert John “Mutt” Lange. ‘Nuff said. (Read an in-depth look at Mutt Lange’s incredible body of work here.)
And the band plays on! Def Leppard continues to produce some GREAT songs. They may not top the charts anymore — the music industry has changed drastically over the decades — but the quality of work is still there.
“Adrenalize” and “Euphoria” had their share of favorites from “Let’s Get Rocked,” “Stand Up (Kick Love into Motion),” and “Have You Ever Needed Someone So Bad,” to “Promises,” “Demolition Man,” “Back in Your Face,” and “To Be Alive.”
“Slang” had some wonderfully written compositions like “All I Want is Everything” and “Where Does Love Go When It Dies,” not to mention other great tracks like “Turn to Dust” and “Pearl of Euphoria.”
Poppy (and, admittedly, unpopular to some) “X” had “Unbelievable,” “Long, Long Way to Go,” “Everyday,” and one of the catchiest choruses they’ve ever written with the underrated “Torn to Shreds.”
“Songs from the Sparkle Lounge” had “Tomorrow” and “Love,” which I believe could have been one of the band’s greatest epics, if only one more verse was added to the song’s second half to balance it out a bit more. (Just my humble opinion!)
Their album “Def Leppard” includes a plethora of good songs, including fan-favorite “We Belong,” which features each band member singing lead vocals for the first time. Overall, the album showcases many different musical flavors for Def Leppard fans to choose from and enjoy.
And I haven’t even mentioned the numerous single-ready, high-quality B-sides the band has put out over the years (for example, “I Wanna Be Your Hero” or the original version of “Tear it Down”) or one-off tracks they included in compilations and live albums (like “Fractured Love,” “Desert Song,” “Kings of the World” and so on…and so on).
The band has continued to churn out new music and appease long-time fans with their relentless touring, including a massive, successful co-headlining tour with Journey, hitting arenas and stadiums throughout the country. (As for their planned stadium tour with Motley Crue, much more about that can be read here.)
More Def Leppard Releases
Several more releases from Def Leppard in recent years:
“We All Need Christmas”
The band’s first-ever, holiday-themed ballad is available via digital download: Amazon MP3 and iTunes.
“The Story So Far: The Best of Def Leppard”
Their latest greatest hits compilation (the band’s third) features many classic tracks PLUS Def Leppard’s cover version of Depeche Mode’s “Personal Jesus.”
Multiple versions of this greatest hits set are available, including a: 2-CD Deluxe Set, 1-CD Set, 2-LP vinyl Set, Amazon MP3 version and iTunes standard and deluxe versions.
If you only want to download “Personal Jesus,” you can get it here: Amazon MP3 / iTunes
An analysis comparing the differences between Def Leppard’s greatest hits releases — Vault, Rock of Ages: The Definitive Collection, and The Story So Far can be found here.
“Hysteria: The Singles” Box Set
This limited-edition 10-disc vinyl box set is also available and includes all the singles (and excellent B-sides!) from the “Hysteria” album, plus a booklet featuring a complete discography, and an introduction written by Joe Elliott.
You can read a lot more information about Def Leppard and the band’s latest releases here.
Def Leppard’s Ongoing Perseverance And Influence
After all these decades, there haven’t been public spats or breakups in the band, and no money-grabbing “farewell” tours (that aren’t even really farewells) or subsequent “reunion” tours.
Over the years, their music and influence have also crossed over. Country star Tim McGraw performed on their song “Nine Lives.” And speaking of country, Taylor Swift’s first choice was to perform with Def Leppard on CMT’s Crossroads concert. Mariah Carey even remade “Bringin’ on the Heartbreak.” And do you remember the musical/movie Rock of Ages?
One Direction’s song “Midnight Memories” caught the attention of many who instantly recognized their song as a ripoff of “Pour Some Sugar on Me.” The only question was whether Def Leppard would sue them — they didn’t.
And let’s not forget all the copycat 80’s bands who unsuccessfully tried to sound like Def Leppard. I’m not even going to bother naming any of them, but I’m sure you can think of a few.
Yes, both Bon Jovi and Def Leppard have sold an enormous amount of records. But it’s about so much more than that; it’s about the mark they leave behind.
“Hysteria” marked its 30th anniversary in 2017 and still sounds just as fresh today.
By the way, if you ever want to read more about the band’s earlier years, leading up to the “Hysteria” album release, I highly recommend the rare, out-of-print book “Def Leppard: Animal Instinct” by David Fricke. It was originally released in 1987 and features many interesting, candid stories about each band member, including legendary, original guitarist Steve Clark. It also includes a very insightful look into drummer Rick Allen’s car accident — the tragedy and, ultimately, the resulting triumph — and so much more. (Another book option for Def Leppard fans can be found here.)
Def Leppard: Rock And Roll Hall of Fame Or Not — The Band’s Songs Stand The Test Of Time
Guitarist Phil Collen looked back on “Hysteria” and talked about its impact and legacy:
“Especially when you have guitar geniuses like Joe Satriani, Paul Gilbert, Steve Vai, and Brian May actually saying to you, ‘That is amazing guitar work.’ Y’know, Prince has mentioned it, Stevie Wonder has mentioned it. Alice Cooper actually said to me, ‘Whenever I go into the studio, I throw ‘Hysteria’ on, just to hear how the room sounds.”
I Don’t Want Your, I Don’t Need Your… Hall of Fame Induction!
Lead singer Joe Elliott originally said, he’d “politely refuse” if Def Leppard were asked to be inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. (Ironically, Jon Bon Jovi offered him Hall of Fame advice after Def Leppard was nominated.)
Phil Collen originally shared a similar view, saying “I don’t know [if we will ever get inducted] and I don’t care, really.” He added, “The way I look at it, I’ve got two diamond albums sitting on my mantelpiece…That means the fans went out and bought it, so that means a lot more to me.”
What’s Taken The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame So Long?
What I know for sure is that Def Leppard’s achievements and contributions to rock n’ roll music are indisputable, but don’t tell me Bon Jovi is more deserving of being inducted first between the two bands.
It’s just not true.
Pour Some Sugar On Me…mories
Regardless of the 19 years it took for Def Leppard’s Hall of Fame induction to happen, looking back at blasting their music on the radio while cruising around, or rushing home to catch MTV’s “world premiere” of their latest music video, or getting in line at a record store to purchase one of their albums — on CD, cassette, or vinyl — remains a cherished memory.
It was also very welcomed news that Def Leppard’s entire catalog was finally released digitally! (You can check out the band’s complete digital catalog on iTunes here.)
Hopefully, a whole new generation will discover and enjoy some great music.
Def Leppard Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Timing
Do you think Bon Jovi deserved to be inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame before Def Leppard, not to mention so many other overlooked, worthy artists?
Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments below.
Rob Hartsell says
Hear, hear! Couldn’t have said it any better. Just got back from the second show at The Forum in LA. What struck me was the multi-generational crowd. Pretty much all age groups were very well represented. A rock band formed in the 70’s having that kind of reach in 2018 is more than impressive.
Nostalgic Logic (Admin) says
Thanks for the comment! Your observations sum up the band’s perseverance and the timelessness of their music very well!
Richard Bliek says
Great article! You named two of my favorite Def Leppard songs ,To Be Alive and Torn to Shreds that just don’t get ANY mention that are just great songs! You can go DEEP into the Def Leppard catalog and find some GREAT songs try doing that with Bon Jovi ! And I really like Bon Jovi but there are just a few bands that has such a awesome and deep catalog! PERIOD! Not up for discussion!
Nostalgic Logic (Admin) says
Thanks for the feedback! Yes, even if you take away all of Def Leppard’s “hit singles,” they have so many other song gems — from their deep tracks to all their great B-sides over the years, etc. The band has an exemplary catalog!
Shannon Mc Glinchey Bounds says
So well said and written!!!! Def Leppard is my favorite band and always will be! So glad someone else “gets” my band!!! Thank you so much!!!
Nostalgic Logic (Admin) says
You’re very welcome! Thank YOU for the comment and your kind words. It’s always great to hear from a fellow fan!
Michael Williams says
I grew up in the 80s and I must say it’s hard to put any kind of decision between these two bands. I personally love them both so I can’t really say… Do I think that def Leppard is worthy, absolutely… They have been around longer, and sold many albums… But to say one is more worthy than the other would be well… Just wrong… I think that after all these years and both bands accomplishments we should rather celebrate them then compare them…
I agree. Regarding 80s glam the only other band that should get in. Is Motley Crue!! & I could give 1000 reasons why! Scorpions as well., there not glam though naturally Priest maiden on the metal side!
Don Cheshire says
I read a very depressing article written by a former member of the Rolling Stones( Bill Wyman) . He is not impressed with Def Leppard and basically ranked them last when he rated all the RR Hof members from 1 to 221.
I sent him a message thru Facebook….. be he never replied back… How the hell could he rank “The Zombies” ahead of Journey, Bon Jovi, and Leppard ? Time of the Season being the only song I know that went anywhere …. Another poor choice when you have Eddie Money and others way more deserving…..
Nostalgic Logic (Admin) says
Thanks for your comment! Yes, I saw that ranking and disregarded most of it (for reasons you mentioned, as well as him placing Queen near the bottom of his list too, saying they’re the most overrated band in history, etc.). That being said, I also read that the writer is a rock critic who shares the same name as Bill Wyman from the Rolling Stones. (Link: https://www.sfgate.com/politics/joegarofoli/article/Can-Bill-Wyman-be-Bill-Wyman-No-says-Bill-Wyman-2715728.php)